There's an anti-intellectual movement out there; angry, scared and frustrated people want validation; sugar for the soul in the short term, but it rots you to the core over time. Then, there's the reasoned, balanced approach of making a case and backing it up.
I would say, we need both. Balance, not competition, is what is required; if you're too busy tipping to the sides, your forward mobility is limited.
Go watch Bill Clinton's DNC 2012 speech for an example of how to best bridge those two approaches.
